It's hard to believe I haven't been in the lab for almost two weeks, but I'm back! It actually feels good. I've said before that being a busy-body at work makes me happy. Happier than if I were just sitting at home. I don't think I'm meant to be a house-wife. I enjoy having a career, even if that career is being a grad student which no one in my family seems to understand what that means.
__
We went home to Appalachia for the holidays, and I got to spend a lot of time with my niece and nephew. Now that they're older (3rd grade), I can communicate with them better. I remember 3rd grade being a good year; it was the year I learned about photosynthesis and became fascinated with it. My sis-in-law had asked me to help them with a science fair project, and I'd heard that they wanted to do something with what I do. After spending many days thinking about how to get them interested in streams, I finally realized that I had the perfect tool to reach them! The
5E lesson plan!
The 5E plan is a peer reviewed method for teaching science to elementary aged kids. The first E is Engage, and that's what I focused on this trip. It may sound a bit self-centered, but I tried to get them interested in what it is I do. As we were driving to some relative's house, I noticed that we were riding along the creek that eventually goes by the kids' house. It had rained the night before and the creek was high and turbid. So I started asking questions about what they thought was going on with the creek. It was like pulling teeth. My niece is like me, not afraid to just shout out answers even if they're wrong. My nephew on the other hand is extremely quiet, and even when we got her to let him answer, there was no response. After a couple of minutes of long silence between answers, I tried a different angle.
"Do you know what it is I do?" I asked
"You're a teacher at college." was the response
NO. Since moving to NYC, I actually do very little teaching. And last year, I even specifically asked my in-laws to tell the kids, should they ask, that I am a scientist. I thought it was important for them to know that they had a direct line to a real-life scientist (as opposed to a teacher, which they might put on the same level as the ones they see every day). I did not want to make this distinction, scientist vs. teacher, because I don't respect teachers or anything like that. But a scientist has a DIFFERENT connotation from teacher. It conjures up a different mental image, and that was what I wanted them to realize.
This trip home has led me to some conclusions, be they right or wrong. 1) I don't think kids are really expected to learn anything in elementary school, beyond basic reading/writing and math skills. Sure other topics and lessons will be thrown at them in the hopes that something sticks, but if it does it's just gravy; a bonus, not expected. 2) What science education is going on at the elementary level (at least in this corner of Appalachia) focuses on getting students to memorize a sequence of "key terms" in a particular order. For example, my niece said she learned the water cycle and so we asked her to tell it to us. She started reciting, "Evaporation, Condensation, Precipitation" as if that was all there is to it. When we tried to get her to define those words, it was done in the context of a memorized story that I recognized from a
Project Wild! lesson. Branching out from the memorized scenario was hard going.
I really shouldn't be surprised. I used to teach future elementary school teachers how to teach biology at an elementary level. They exhibited the same difficulties. They wanted a list of the key terms and the order to memorize them in. In exams, I would try to use different scenarios from what was taught in class, always with disastrous results and complaints (both from the students and higher ups). I shouldn't be surprised that this is what their students are able to retain, it's all they get.
But I had higher hopes for my niece and nephew....after all, they have a dedicated science teacher! Even in elementary school, these kids rotate throughout the day to different periods; Home Room, Reading & Writing, Art, Math, History, and Science. There's a whole period for science!!! If the school is going to have a dedicated science teacher, then I expect that person to be a bit better at teaching science than a teacher that has to be able to teach everything. Is that wrong?
Do I expect too much of this school? Or my niece and nephew? Or my family? Am I a bitch?